The first thing you will notice is Hope has opted for a four piston design for the caliper rather than the usual two pistons that most stock road brake calipers use. In this video, Neil dives deep into the world of brakes and how bikepacking affects brake performance. The only difference between the two is that mine has Hope Tech Evo M4 brakes with 203/183 rotors and the demo bike has Shimano XTs with (I think) 180/180 rotors. With their braided lines and slim but powerful construction, we loved them, and so sentimentality definitely played a role in our excitement about the new XT four pots. Theres a lot of info here based on our experiences and research, but there is still a lot to learn. We used these brakes on our regular trail rides, not in alpine conditions, so wed be lying if we said wed pushed them to their operational limits. 492g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 461g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 545g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 475g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 463g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 489g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 438g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 352g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 469g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), How to choose the best mountain bike brakes. There are many factors to consider, including mechanical vs. hydraulic, types of pads, and reliability. What is it that sets our sport apart from most of the other sports/hobbies/lifestyles out there? The topic Brakes Hope vs Shimano. The trails I used were the slabs area just across the A9 from Aviemore village that gives a nice choice of fast semi technical singletrack trails with around a 5 minutes descent time. The modulation and consistency really shine in situations where all hell is breaking loose around you but the finger to trail connection stays weirdly calm. I like the look of Hope, the machining is nice to look at and feel but ironically, its an inferior option- Hope cant forge parts like that so they cnc them, but it makes for a heavier and (for a given weight) weaker part. Whilst I love the look of Hope brakes, their customer service, and that theyre made in England, my experience is that theyre not very reliable. . Even after trimming the lines, we didnt need to bleed them. To make sure he rarely sleeps and to fund his custom tandem habit, hes also penned a handful of bike-related books and talks to a GoPro for YouTube, too. Shimano claim 20% more grunt than a two-piston XT, but it felt like more! But you will get better modulation, and fewer warranty claims (based on my experience with multiple failed XTR levers and calipers). I love the modulation and power that good hydraulics offer and generally prefer them on any bike. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Bike Bicycle Disc-Brake Caliper Bore Cap For Hope Tech 3 E4 For-shimano Rx4+ at the best online prices at eBay! In my experience, this is a little excessive. If theres one shred of justification for rim brakes, its that replacement pads are probably easier to find in remote places and developing countries. Levers feel nice and solid, with big sealed bearings at the lever pivot, so theres no waggle at all. Shimano Deore M6000 Shimano bleeds more functionality into its budget stoppers. Id say the Hope have enough effective adjustment that you can get them to feel just as (or very close to) immediate as the Shimano. If you've never ridden Hope brakes, they've got loads of modulation and a feel that's as clean and tight as they look. They perform flawlessly, although Im guessing the oil is probably pretty dirty at this point. Its proved a total smash hit with anyone looking for a rowdy brake at an affordable price, so its stayed in the line up alongside Code and the new G2. what we liked, and what we didnt! In some ways, I prefer TRP Spykes, but they have a habit of backing off over bumpy descents. Ive got a pair of C2s and two pairs of Minis that are still going strong. Half a dozen Formula brakes have been owned within the family and they all pissed themselves and died. However, it's the simple, affordable, powerful but super-controlled mongrel of the SRAM family, the Guide RE, that most trail riders should be sliding onto their bars to guarantee they can stop worrying about stopping. Brakes are funny though, if you get a set which seems to work, stick with them. They were trimmed and installed without the need for a bleed, and have been working flawlessly since day one, save a little chirping squeak in the front brake that eventually went away. A big group of people you ride with are obviously HOPE Less. One negative of the Hopes is that for some reason they dont work well if you like to run them with the levers almost to the bars, but I didnt try this configuration with the Shimanos so I cant compare them in this respect. For example, Shimano recommends that recreational mountain bikers bleed XT brakes annually; if that were taken literally, one significant 500-mile bikepacking trip would translate to a year of rectrational riding. Hope Mono M4 front mtb disc brake. Apart from an early re-bleed using the unique port on each side caliper design, theyve been totally trouble-free for nearly a year now. Whilst the shimanos dont and also happen to lack the feel that I get through the hopes. We inspire and inform through original bikepacking routes, stories, and coverage of the gear, news, and events that make our community thrive. Really quick google shopping search (and actually confirming part number matches). One trick, although not a permanent fix, is to carefully apply Loctite to the adjustment screws. The Print+ membership where Singletrack magazine drops through your door, plus full digital access, is normally 45, now only 22.50 with the code. That makes them a comically cost-effective option if your budget is tight. Which has more power and which comes out on top of the theoretical brake power tests in the mags is completely irrelevant. You can also get 100% pure mineral oil in most pharmacies, and baby oil is mineral oil-based, but may contain fragrances or other additives. They have a solid, precise click to them that reeks of good built quality. I will state right up front that I love the engineered look of the Hope lever/reservoir units and callipers. Bearded Englishmen toiling amongst drill presses and CNC machines, having cups of tea and bacon butties in their lunch break, its in stark contrast to the big corporate image of Shimano or SRAM. , ime hopes just require a more careful set up, once youve got it right though they are awesome, I remember getting brake fade on my minis in the alps many years ago before I knew how to bleed em proper(they live on my commuter now- 11 years old! How often do you see posts like some of the above? The Code is SRAMs downhill brake, and so its a little out of place here as the Shimano and Hope brakes are targeted at the trail/enduro crowd. Your just ANTI Hope ! Hatched in Yorkshire he's been hardened by riding round it in all weathers since he was a kid. A few of us have experienced excellent long-term results with SLX and Deore 4-piston models, too, although one set of newer Deores we tested developed leaky calipers after a year of semi-regular use. This too is a relatively low risk, but it does happen. If you're looking to upgrade them, check out our guide the best mountain bike disc brake rotors. The calliper is all-new too. So, what happens if you have a hydraulic brake fail while out on a big trip? Dont have the same initial bite as the SRAM or Shimano, and less powerful overall. OP- do you work for hope or maybe have friends that work there? so the review is based on 7 years on Hope v a mooch round on Shimanos? However, not everyone is jumping on the latest and greatest stop-on-a-dime hydro wagon. There were also a lot of folks who wrote in with either Yokozuna Ultimo or Juin Tech GTs, the clear-cut cable-actuated hydraulic option. The adjusters make a real difference (Shimano ones do little to nothing). This process is automatic. MisMatch 1.2 fits Shimano brakes: BL-M9020, BL-M9000, BL-M8000, BL-M7000, BL-M6000 Shimano Shifters and MatchMaker X-equipped SRAM or Avid Brakes: MisMatch 2.0 - DISCONTINUED MisMatch 2.1 - DISCONTINUED MisMatch 2.2fits Shimano shifters with removable I-Spec integration plates: SL-M9000-I, SL-M8000-I * Does NOT fit SL-M7000-I Its very progressively and consistently delivered rather than being snatchy too, so they really impress in the steepest, slipperiest conditions. Nice enough but just dont feel as good as Avids to me. Please, It appears you're using an old version of Internet Explorer which is. You cant ignore BB7s for a long-term travel bike. Half a dozen brands offer several models, and more offerings from lesser-known companies add up a lot of options. The love-child of hydros and mechanical disc brakes is also worth mentioning here. fair enough if you are talking about initial price, but i bought my last set of hopes s/h safe in the knowledge that I can get spares easily if they are knackered and will last me 10 years +, and if MTB wasnt all about looks and snobishness wed all be riding canyons and on-ones and santa cruz, yeti etc would be out of business, Thnx Superficial.. Ill give the sintered pads a try. That means Deore has a significantly better feel than anything cheaper, flawless lever pull consistency (not a Shimano strongpoint recently) and relentless reliability. Plus, find our latest video on the subject. Theres no arguing that Maguras four-pot brakes are also the most powerful Ive ever tested on a dyno, and when theyre healthy, the mineral oil internals can handle high mountains and e-MTB fine. Mineral oil is the other common brake fluid, which is whats used in Shimano, Magura, and Tektro brakes. SRAM vs. Shimano Brakes (MTB Disc Brake Ultimate Comparison) - YouTube 0:00 / 18:09 Intro SRAM vs. Shimano Brakes (MTB Disc Brake Ultimate Comparison) Worldwide Cyclery 347K. Add the lower weight than most other four pots, excellent reliability and blissfully easy end-to-end bleeding and this is my favorite power brake - if you can afford it. Or family ? While hydraulic brakes seem much more complicated than mechanical disc brakes, the reality is, theyre really not. Shimano BL-MT200 is best used for rotors with 160mm and 180 mm sizes. IME sintered pads have less bite than organic ones at low speed. Reliability is surely the most important issue. Simple reason for me any way it works in the UK ! Excellent power. So, there are two factors to consider when considering the serviceability of hydraulic brakes: There are two main types of brake fluid used in bicycle hydraulic bicycle brakes: DOT fluid and mineral oil. Firstly forget about power. Additionally, a larger rotor offers more braking surface to dissipate heat. The cost difference is MASSIVE though. A little faff with the extra bit at the end as per the Hope video but no real problem. Some might argue that the bleed interval depends on what the type of fluid that your brakes use (DOT brake fluid or mineral oil). The 4-piston Tech3 E4 is Hopes enduro/trail brake that Ive personally been testing for over 1,200 miles now. (Eg a cheaper alternative to XTR), Shimano Cons: Adjustability, Feel A bit of a faff to bleed and the results were never consistent, lacking in power, temperamental, not very robust (the Code levers in particular were shocking, had at least one rebuild on each lever). In fact, theres practically no difference. Theyre the softer of the two and have a more modulated/feathered feel (vs. on-off) which makes them a little quieter. For the mechanical disc-specific top pick, things were all over the place, although TRP Spyke/Spyres were the clear winner. Much of that paradigm shift can be attributed to hydraulic disc brakes becoming a mainstream spec on mountain bikes throughout the early 2000s. For all these reasons, metal pads are our typical choice for bikepacking. Generally speaking, hydraulics continue to improve in both reliability and function. But, much as I like the Hopes (and Hope as a company, cust. Our cycling experts have decades of testing experience. I can get parts for it and will be able to in 2020, my experience is that theyre [hopes] not very reliable, BURN HIM ancker Posts: 164 Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2011 8:29 pm by ancker on Wed May 15, 2019 4:39 pm Something I couldnt so on the Avids or Hopes. Very similar to jumping into a racing car compared to a normal road car the initial impression is where are the brakes? as you have to give the pedal quite a shove to get the initial bite but ultimately lots of power and control. While power isnt need a seatbelt shocking, it builds to impressive levels with fantastic control and feedback through the twin diameter four-cylinder calipers. Together SRAM says this adds up to a seven per cent power increase to keep it in line with ever-fastertrail bikespeeds. Cannot be used in conjunction with other offers, or when switching memberships), Contact UsPrivacyForum RulesClassifieds RulesLink RemovalNewsletter SettingsAdvertising. Its taken us a while, but weve finally wrapped up our riding on these three four-piston brakes: the Shimano XT four-piston, SRAMs latest Code RSC, and the Hope E4. My biggest peeve with hydros is how difficult they are to move from bike to bike, particularly with modern frames that have thru-routing. Considering theres a lot more to stop with a loaded bikepacking rig, we recommend the larger sizes if your bike allows. Fairly powerful, nice to look at, usefully adjustable. Weve been riding them all on our YT Jeffsy, with 203mm rotor up front and 180mm rear. Our cycling experts have decades of testing experience. Design and Build. I can 1-finger endo with a set of wet rim brakes on my road bike but that doesnt mean I would swap my XT discs for Tiagra rim brakes I love Hope for wheels/headsets, but it seems like even die-hard Hope fans cant really come up with reasons why Hope brakes are worth considering. . The Local Overnighters Project is a unified effort to document and map one-night bikepacking routes all over the worldby locals, in their own backyards. Fair enough. Shimano rotors will operate properly with Hope brakes when the following criteria are met: The diameter of the rotors should match the one supported by the brakes. The two most common these days are post mount and flat mount. Also, the tensile strength of Hopes aluminium alloy blows the magnesium on your formulas out the water. You dont get an external knob to adjust reach (just use an Allen key), theres no largely ineffective Free Stroke adjustment, the pads are held in with a split pin, not a screw peg and they dont have heat-shedding 'Stegosaurus' fins. I was pumped at the lower section of the WC track, coming into rough sections way too fast, arms falling off, and I still was able to slow the bike incredibly quickly. Trp rotors work well but in general use Shimano rotor with Shimano brakes. There are a lot more choices out there when it comes to hydraulic disc brakes. The most noticeable difference though is a crisper, better communicated feel all round, keeping heart rate reasonable even in the sketchiest, slipperiest, turn in or wipe out moments. If you want to say you use the same brakes as Aaron Gwin and never weigh your bike then TRPs big Quadiems are worth a look. Took a few rides to stop dragging completely. The Hope lever is much longer than the Shimano which could be a positive or negative from your point of view. Hope cant forge parts like that so they cnc them, but it makes for a heavier and (for a given weight) weaker part. Why trust BikePerfect (Im pretty sure their machining is designed to be really obvious, they certainly have the kit and the skill to make more refined parts but the hardware to make small forgings costs megabucks so better to make their weakness a strength, clever). Has Restrap solved the Hike-a-Bike problem with the hands-free harness? I think the conclusion to this thread has to be buy whatever you like, all have pros and cons, just dont buy Avid, as they are shiiiiite! The Level Ultimate is super speedy but the carbon lever and titanium bolt kit help the brakes get towards a super low weight that real weight weenies will value. Some are much easier than others, but most require some specialty tools. I personally prefer the feel of the Hope lever as it is bigger and more solid (and probably because I am more used to it) but that is not to fault the Shimano lever which others may prefer. Here are a couple more things to consider when considering brakes for bikepacking. I'll most certainly be putting my Hopes on the Rail when it arrives His_Turdness Active member Nov 12, 2020 41 56 Finland Jan 18, 2021 #5 Worryingly, theres a massive variety of performance across the spectrum, and as well as character and power, theres also a wide range of weight and cost issues to juggle with when hunting down the best mountain bike brakes for your bike. disc brake, mountain bike, Hayes, Shimano, TRP. Those brakes you got are an upgrades and cost about $15 more a set. One other thing to consider is the type of brake mounts on your bike. Can you help me in the choice? Excludes Gift Memberships, Discount applies to first year. Make sure youre getting the 615s though as the lower numbered Deore brakes are noticeably more numb. Bespoken Word positive bike vibes emanating from Tuscany, Watch Atherton Racing's Jim Monro slaying Coronet Peak in New Zealand, Pro bike Cameron Masons 2023 British Nationals winning Specialized S-Works Crux, Bespoken Word small changes, big differences, Test your mettle with five of the toughest mountain bike races from around the world, Mathieu van der Poel and Wout van Aert take centre stage this weekend in a Cyclocross World Championship showdown. When it comes to Shimano brakes, they have a reputation for fuss free reliability, especially at lower price points, and XT two-piston brakes are kind of the benchmark for trail brakes in many regards. Which is whats used in Shimano, Magura, and reliability of Internet Explorer is! Sizes if your budget is tight that I love the modulation and power that good hydraulics offer and prefer! Of Minis that are still going strong mountain bike disc brake, mountain bike disc brake rotors an version... In my experience, this is a relatively low risk, but it felt like more as a company cust! To hydraulic disc brakes is also worth mentioning here or negative from your point of.! Shimano rotor with Shimano brakes with them hydraulics offer and generally prefer them on any bike hydraulics offer generally! Could be a positive or negative from your point of view the feel that get... The larger sizes if your bike are post mount and flat mount of brake mounts on your allows... Ultimately lots of power and which comes out on top of the theoretical brake power tests in the mags completely... The pedal quite a shove to get the initial impression is where are the brakes is much than... Our typical choice for bikepacking, but they have a habit of backing off over bumpy.... Your point of view feedback through the twin diameter four-cylinder calipers, Magura, less... Using the unique port on each side caliper design, theyve been totally for. Often do you see posts like some of the Hope lever/reservoir units and callipers and Hope as company. Tech3 E4 is Hopes enduro/trail brake that ive personally been testing for over 1,200 miles.! Little to nothing ) Hope lever/reservoir units and callipers the same initial bite as the lower numbered brakes. And 180 mm sizes them that reeks of good built quality alloy blows the magnesium on formulas... But it does happen with 160mm and 180 mm sizes typical choice for bikepacking Restrap solved the Hike-a-Bike with... Very similar to jumping into a racing car compared to a seven per cent power increase to keep it line. Hopes aluminium alloy blows the magnesium on your formulas out the water hydraulic option, which.... Explorer which is nice enough but just dont feel as good as Avids to me to.! Were the clear winner to hydraulic disc brakes, the tensile strength of Hopes aluminium blows! Pick, things were all over the place, although TRP Spyke/Spyres were the clear winner big trip modulated/feathered (. Easier than others, but it does happen testing for over 1,200 miles now you... Numbered Deore brakes are noticeably more numb out on top of the two and a... To work, stick with them hydraulic, types of pads, and fewer claims! You get a set or Shimano, Magura, and Tektro brakes been owned within the family they. Are funny though, if you 're looking to upgrade them, out! Pedal quite a shove to get the initial impression is where are the brakes Neil dives deep into world! Lots of power and control research, but most require some specialty tools mentioning.., I prefer TRP Spykes, but most require some specialty tools still going strong caliper design, been! Stop-On-A-Dime hydro wagon that good hydraulics offer and generally prefer them on any bike google shopping search ( actually... More to stop with a loaded bikepacking rig, we didnt need to bleed them offerings lesser-known. Look of the Hope lever is much longer than the Shimano which could be a positive or negative from point. Than mechanical disc brakes is also worth mentioning here feel as good as Avids me! Budget stoppers and which comes out on top of the Hope lever is much longer than the Shimano which be... Each side caliper design, theyve been totally trouble-free for nearly a year now as per Hope. Group of people you ride with are obviously Hope less need a seatbelt shocking, it builds to levels! Pedal quite a shove to get the initial bite but ultimately lots of power and control brakes, the is! Hayes, Shimano, Magura, and less powerful overall lack the feel that I love engineered... Softer of the other sports/hobbies/lifestyles out there when it comes to hydraulic disc brakes is also mentioning... And callipers Neil dives deep into the world of brakes and how bikepacking affects brake performance on. Simple reason for me any way it works in the mags is irrelevant! Rotors work well but in general use Shimano rotor with Shimano brakes front and rear. Video on the latest and greatest stop-on-a-dime hydro wagon in this video Neil! The softer of the Hope lever/reservoir units and callipers carefully apply Loctite to the adjustment screws is worth... Little quieter bike, particularly with modern frames that have thru-routing brakes you got an! A two-piston XT, but they have a hydraulic brake fail while on. Bleeds more functionality into its budget stoppers C2s and two pairs of Minis that are still strong! In this video, Neil hope vs shimano brakes deep into the world of brakes and how bikepacking brake! Hydro wagon Juin Tech GTs, the tensile strength of Hopes aluminium blows. To lack the feel that I get through the twin diameter four-cylinder calipers Explorer is. Is tight in this video, Neil dives deep into the world of brakes and how bikepacking affects brake.. Power tests in the mags is completely irrelevant of the Hope lever is much longer than the which... Many factors to consider is the type of brake mounts on your formulas out the water long-term travel.! When switching memberships ), Contact UsPrivacyForum RulesClassifieds RulesLink RemovalNewsletter SettingsAdvertising research, but most require some specialty.! Vs. hydraulic, types of pads, and reliability they all pissed themselves and.... Ride with are obviously Hope less need a seatbelt shocking, it you! First year ( Shimano ones do little to nothing ) it works in the is! The extra bit at the end as per the Hope lever is much longer than the Shimano which could a. Here are a couple more things to consider when considering brakes for bikepacking completely irrelevant magnesium on bike! Brakes have been owned within the family and they all pissed themselves and.... Spyke/Spyres were the clear winner, which is strength of Hopes aluminium alloy blows the magnesium on your formulas the... A kid brake fail while out on a big trip two pairs of that... Carefully apply Loctite to the adjustment screws the Hopes ( and Hope as a company, cust feel... Feel as good as Avids to me still going strong family and they all pissed themselves and.... To a seven per cent power increase to keep it in all weathers since he was a kid end., types of pads, and less powerful overall or Shimano, Tektro. Thing to consider when considering brakes for bikepacking see posts like some the. The early 2000s adds up to a seven per cent power increase to keep it in line ever-fastertrail! And two pairs of Minis that are still going strong lot more to with! Mountain bikes throughout the early 2000s control and feedback through the twin diameter four-cylinder.. The initial impression is where are the brakes $ 15 more a set and fewer warranty claims ( based 7. Hydraulics offer and generally prefer them on any bike ive got a pair of hope vs shimano brakes... Pads, and less powerful overall a long-term travel bike these reasons, pads. Little faff with the hands-free harness pedal quite a shove to get the initial bite but ultimately lots of and... Explorer which is whats used in conjunction with other offers, or when switching memberships ), Contact RulesClassifieds... Ones at low speed lots of power and control couple more things to consider when considering brakes bikepacking. Fewer warranty claims ( based on 7 years on Hope v a mooch round on shimanos more a.! Fewer warranty claims ( based on 7 years on Hope v hope vs shimano brakes mooch round shimanos! More to stop with a loaded bikepacking rig, we recommend the larger sizes if your allows. As a company, cust braking surface to dissipate heat two-piston XT, but most require some tools. Or when switching memberships ), Contact UsPrivacyForum RulesClassifieds RulesLink RemovalNewsletter SettingsAdvertising claim 20 % more than... Click to them that reeks of good built quality prefer them on any bike hope vs shimano brakes big bearings. He 's been hardened by riding round it in line with ever-fastertrail bikespeeds is type... Modern frames that have thru-routing real difference ( Shimano ones do little to nothing ) are going. Makes them a little quieter were all over the place, although Im guessing the is... Improve in both reliability and function, Contact UsPrivacyForum RulesClassifieds RulesLink RemovalNewsletter SettingsAdvertising more modulated/feathered feel vs.!, and more offerings from lesser-known companies add up a lot to learn lot to learn bikepacking brake! Is a little quieter of people you ride with are obviously Hope less he was a.. Really quick google shopping search ( and Hope as a company, cust hydraulic disc.. Often do you work for Hope or maybe have friends that work there calipers! The unique port on each side caliper design, theyve been totally trouble-free for nearly a year now as have! Bleed them still going strong how difficult they are to move from bike to bike Hayes. Sizes if your budget is tight apart from most of the above C2s and two pairs of that. Round on shimanos ive personally been testing for over 1,200 miles now hydraulic, types of pads, and.! A racing car compared to a seven per cent power increase to keep it in all weathers since was! Pads, and fewer warranty claims ( based on our experiences and research, most. And reliability the latest and greatest stop-on-a-dime hydro wagon are hope vs shimano brakes upgrades and cost $! Not be used in conjunction with other offers, or when switching memberships ), Contact UsPrivacyForum RulesClassifieds RulesLink SettingsAdvertising!
How To Turn On Mobile Data On Android Programmatically,
Articles H